Menu

The 21 Best Restaurants between Chicago and Indianapolis

Exploring the culinary scene between Chicago and Indianapolis can be an exciting journey for food lovers. Whether you're craving a delicious steak, authentic Mexican cuisine, or a mouthwatering slice of pizza, there are plenty of options to choose from along the way.

For those looking to compare and find the best dining options between these two cities, this list of the 21 Best Restaurants between Chicago and Indianapolis is a valuable resource. From fine dining establishments to casual eateries, there is something for every palate and budget along this route.

How this ranking works

The order here is based on merit: a business that focuses on this work and has a solid reputation ranks above one that only offers it on the side.

Some businesses pay for a fuller profile or a featured position. It is only open to those that have already passed our selection, and it is always marked.

Top 3Full rankingMapTips for choosing

Our 21 local picks compared

St. Elmo Steak House, Chicago#1
What sets it apart
  • Impeccable service from veteran waitstaff

  • Exceptional food quality, especially the steaks

  • Unique and flavorful cocktails

  • Stunning historic atmosphere

St. Elmo Steak House

4.75,172 reviews
127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States

St. Elmo Steak House is an iconic steakhouse located in Indianapolis, known for its rich history and exquisite dining experience. The restaurant offers a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, making it convenient for all types of diners.

With a rating of 4.7 out of 5, based on 5172 reviews, St. Elmo Steak House is highly praised by its patrons. Some key points highlighted in the reviews include:

Customers rave about the shrimp cocktail, seafood pasta, and king crab Mac and cheese. The restaurant is popular for lunch and dinner, making it a great choice for any meal. The intimate and cozy atmosphere combined with top-notch service truly sets St. Elmo Steak House apart from the rest.

Harry & Izzy's, Chicago#2
What sets it apart
  • Attentive and personalized service

  • Delicious food with standout dishes like shrimp cocktail

  • Beautiful and welcoming atmosphere

Harry & Izzy's

4.73,561 reviews
153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States

Harry & Izzy's is an iconic American restaurant located in Indianapolis that offers a variety of services and features to enhance the dining experience. Customers can enjoy Outdoor seating, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options. The restaurant is known for its Great coffee, Great dessert, and Great tea selection, making it a popular choice for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining.

Chicago Beef and Dog Company#3
What sets it apart
  • The food was really good, fresh ingredients, all beef dogs, and we had great customer service.

  • The staff was nice and patient with us while we were fumbling with our order.

  • Incredible food, amazing service! Large variety of menu options and large portions, so rest assured there’s something for everybody! Italian beefy cheesy fries are my go to.

  • Excellent food and reasonable prices. Friendly service. Worth the 30 Minute drive every time.

Chicago Beef and Dog Company

4.7981 reviews
5402 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219, United States

Chicago Beef and Dog Company is a popular hot dog restaurant in Indianapolis, offering a variety of services like outdoor seating, delivery, and dine-in options. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients, all beef dogs, and great customer service provided by the staff.

Chicago's Pizza#4
What sets it apart
  • No big surprises, great value for delicious food.

  • Quality pizza at an excellent price, outstanding value for lunch buffet.

  • Favorite pizza place in Indianapolis, known for heart-shaped pizzas and ice cream.

  • Always greeted warmly, fresh and delicious food, best pizza in town.

Chicago's Pizza

4.61,146 reviews
5920 E Stop 11 Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46237, United States

Chicago's Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in Indianapolis, known for its delicious food and fast service. They offer a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, delivery, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy popular offerings like lunch, dinner, and vegetarian options in a casual and cozy atmosphere.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.6, Chicago's Pizza continues to impress customers with their tasty offerings and friendly service. The restaurant is a go-to spot for pizza lovers and families looking for a satisfying meal.

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse, Chicago#5
What sets it apart
  • Experience was enhanced by romantic lighting and live music

  • Staff was personable and friendly

  • Great dessert options and portion sizes

  • Food was delicious and service was exceptional

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

4.6715 reviews
51 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse is known for its exceptional service and exquisite dining experience. With options for Kerbside pickup, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, this steakhouse caters to all preferences. The Fireplace, Great dessert, and Live music add to the already enticing atmosphere. Customers have raved about their experiences, emphasizing on the friendly staff, romantic ambiance, and top-quality food. Here are some key points from recent reviews:

These reviews paint a picture of a memorable dining experience at Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse.

Charleston's Restaurant, Chicago#6
What sets it apart
  • We ate here for the first time tonight and had a wonderful experience! The food was excellent and the portions were huge. We will certainly be back!

  • All the food is good here, service is excellent, and I love the decor and ambiance. The daiquiri was awesome and I would definitely get that again.

  • We always get seated right away and everything we've tried has been great. The crescents and fried catfish are exceptional. Portions are great for the price and we always share.

  • Great food quality, ambiance for relaxing conversations, and friendly staff. The fries are amazing and the baby back ribs are a must-try. A great place for a relaxing evening. Will become one of my main stops!

Charleston's Restaurant

4.52,060 reviews
6815 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States

Charleston's Restaurant is a renowned American restaurant located in Indianapolis, IN. The establishment offers a variety of services including Kerbside pickup, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options. Customers can enjoy fast service, great coffee, delectable desserts, and sporting events in a casual, cosy, and trendy atmosphere.

Key customer reviews:

Chicago’s fish & chicken#7
What sets it apart
  • Food is good when fresh, especially the chicken.

  • Staff are very friendly and welcoming.

  • Fried chicken is crunchy and delicious, prompting a whole song by a satisfied customer.

  • Restaurant is clean, with good food and nice people, but the parking area can use some improvement.

Chicago’s fish & chicken

4.755 reviews
3720 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46235, United States

Chicago’s fish & chicken is a popular restaurant located in Indianapolis, IN. They offer a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Known for their delicious comfort food and quick bites, this restaurant is a favorite spot for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

Customer reviews rave about the fresh and tasty food, with the chicken being a standout. The friendly staff and great customer service also receive high praise. Here are some key points from recent reviews:

If you're looking for a casual dining experience with great food and a friendly atmosphere, be sure to check out Chicago’s fish & chicken for your next meal!

Dick's Last Resort - Indianapolis, Chicago#8
What sets it apart
  • Came here for a quick bite to eat and a drink before an event. The waiters and bartenders are great and attentive, making the experience enjoyable. Strong and well-made drinks add to the appeal.

  • Love the unique attitude at this restaurant. While the food was okay, everything else was great. The humorous insults from the staff create a fun atmosphere.

  • Great place to be insulted in a fun way, while enjoying delicious food and drinks. Outstanding service with a touch of mild insults adds to the experience.

  • We heard about the sarcasm and rudeness from the staff before visiting, and it lived up to the hype. The mac & cheese, jumbo fried shrimp, and chili cheese fries were fantastic. The waitress maintained the humorous atmosphere perfectly.

Dick's Last Resort - Indianapolis

4.42,422 reviews
111 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States

Dick's Last Resort - Indianapolis is a unique and entertaining restaurant located in the heart of Indianapolis. Offering a range of service options like delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, this establishment aims to please all types of customers. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a great spot for any time of day.

With a rating of 4.4, Dick's Last Resort is highly regarded by its patrons. Some recent reviews include:

Customers praise the entertaining atmosphere, excellent food, and outstanding service at Dick's Last Resort - Indianapolis. It's a must-visit spot for anyone looking for a fun dining experience in Indianapolis.

Giordano's, Chicago#9
What sets it apart
  • Delicious, well-seasoned pizza with a crispy crust and deep, flavorful sauce.

  • Friendly staff, spacious interior, and excellent service.

  • Great atmosphere for a casual dining experience.

  • Convenient location and efficient service that delivers an authentic dining experience.

Giordano's

4.41,905 reviews
43 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States

Giordano's is a renowned pizza restaurant located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis, offering a variety of services to cater to every customer's needs. With options for Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, Giordano's ensures convenience and flexibility for all visitors.

A highlighted feature of this establishment is its Fast service, ensuring that patrons receive their delicious meals promptly. Popular among customers for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, Giordano's promises a memorable dining experience for all.

Customer reviews showcase the appeal of Giordano's, with patrons praising the flavorful and authentic Chicago-style pizza. Here are some key points summarized from the reviews:

With a solid rating of 4.4 and over 1905 reviews, Giordano's is a must-visit pizza destination in Indianapolis for pizza enthusiasts and foodies alike.

Portillo’s Indianapolis-IN, Chicago#10
What sets it apart
  • The food at Portillo’s is reminiscent of the delicious offerings in Chicago, with hot dogs, Italian beef, and chocolate cake standing out as favorites.

  • Customers consistently praise the friendly and enthusiastic staff for their exceptional service.

  • The atmosphere at Portillo’s is described as family-friendly and casual, making it a great spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.

  • The cheese for the fries is a must-try according to reviewers, adding an extra layer of flavor to the experience.

Portillo’s Indianapolis-IN

4.33,046 reviews
8150 US 31 S, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States

Portillo’s Indianapolis-IN is a beloved fast-food restaurant located in Indianapolis, IN. With a rating of 4.3 from 3046 reviews, it is clear that customers appreciate what this establishment has to offer.

Portillo’s Indianapolis-IN is not just a restaurant; it's an experience that keeps customers coming back for more. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Chicago hot dog or a hearty Italian beef sandwich, Portillo’s has something for everyone.

Weber Grill Restaurant, Chicago#11
What sets it apart
  • Cute themed restaurant with a decent menu selection and friendly staff.

  • Spacious and beautifully designed restaurant with top-notch food and impeccable service.

  • Atmosphere and service were wonderful, with exceptionally good food.

  • Delicious food, attentive service, and great presentation that exceeded expectations.

Weber Grill Restaurant

4.22,860 reviews
10 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States

Weber Grill Restaurant is a renowned establishment located in the heart of Indianapolis, offering a wide range of services to cater to every customer's needs. From outdoor seating to deliveries and dine-in options, they strive to provide a comfortable and enjoyable dining experience.

The restaurant is known for its fast service, great beer selection, cocktails, and a wine list that will satisfy any connoisseur. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a more upmarket experience, Weber Grill Restaurant has it all.

Customer reviews speak volumes about the quality of food and service provided. Some key points highlighted in the reviews include:

With a solid 4.2-star rating and numerous positive reviews, Weber Grill Restaurant continues to be a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Visit them today for a memorable dining experience!

McCormick & Schmick's Seafood & Steaks, Chicago#12
What sets it apart
  • Outstanding service and delectable food

  • Beautiful decor and great server

  • Impressive calamari and ribeye steak

  • Pricey with small portions, average food

McCormick & Schmick's Seafood & Steaks

4.21,149 reviews
110 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States

McCormick & Schmick's Seafood & Steaks is a renowned Restaurant located in Indianapolis, IN. Known for its exquisite seafood and steaks, this establishment offers a plethora of dining options and amenities. From Kerbside pickup and Delivery to Takeaway and Dine-in services, customers can enjoy their favorite meals at their convenience.

The restaurant is highly praised for its Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Great coffee, Great dessert, and Great wine list, creating a delightful dining experience for all. It is a popular spot for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, catering to various preferences.

Customer reviews highlight the exceptional service and delectable cuisine offered at McCormick & Schmick's Seafood & Steaks. Here are a few key points summarizing the reviews:

Experience the culinary delights and warm ambiance of McCormick & Schmick's Seafood & Steaks for a memorable dining experience.

Tavern On South, Chicago#13
What sets it apart
  • We were a party of 7. Ruby, our server, was fantastic and the food was fresh and delicious. Would definitely eat here again!

  • Visited after a full day at the NFL Combine. Very pleasantly surprised by the fantastic burgers and quick, friendly service.

  • Great Drink Specials Daily. Generous food portions and the best wings in the city. Highly recommended!

  • Atmosphere and the restaurant vibe are great. Bison burger was mediocre, but other meals were enjoyed. Would return again.

Tavern On South

4.2976 reviews
423 W South St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States

Tavern On South is a renowned New American restaurant located in Indianapolis, IN. Offering a variety of services including Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, Takeaway, and Dine-in, this restaurant caters to diverse customer needs. The establishment is highlighted for its Fast service, Great coffee, and Sport atmosphere, making it a favorite spot for many. Customers rave about the delicious food and top-notch service. Here are some summarized reviews:

With a rating of 4.2 based on 976 reviews, Tavern On South continues to be a popular choice for patrons seeking a delightful dining experience.

Jordans Fish Chicken & Gyros (Illinois Street), Chicago#14
What sets it apart
  • Todays visit was great, everything about it! The amazing hospitality and customer service to the great quality of the food. If you’re at this location be sure to ask for the lunch special… decent portion of food a drink and fries! My family and I we well taken care of.

  • Pretty good selection of food and pretty tasty. This was my first visit so I got the wings and perch to start things off. The portion was huge. Normal wings, lots of fries, 3 full size pieces of fish. I think I was supposed to get coleslaw though and didn't. They put a shake seasoning on everything that was excellent. It was a bit greasy, and I think that's from old oil. You could taste that slightly old flavor. The place inside was a mess. Dirty floors and old everything. As long as the grills are clean and the food is good I don't care about that too much though. All in all, it was nice and filling. Not sure I would go there again. I'll keep experimenting until I find a better fish place in the area.

  • I ordered a Large Calamari and fries on Door Dash. They had the fries but not the calamari that I ordered. I’m pretty disappointed because I have heard a lot of good things about this restaurant and this is my first time ordering from here. Just disappointing.

  • After trying the rest, you will get with the best. These guys know how to fry chicken. Awesome job every time. The wings, gyros, fries, are all first rate. The catfish definitely is worth trying.

Jordans Fish Chicken & Gyros (Illinois Street)

4.2712 reviews
2066 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States

Jordans Fish Chicken & Gyros (Illinois Street) is a popular restaurant located in Indianapolis, IN. The establishment offers a wide range of services including No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Customers can enjoy various offerings such as Comfort food, Halal food, Late-night food, and more. The restaurant is known for its Great dessert and is a favorite spot for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining.

Here are some customer reviews:

Spoke & Steele, Chicago#15
What sets it apart
  • The bartender provided top-notch service and crafted amazing drinks, like the best lemon drop martini.

  • The menu offers a range of delectable dishes that satisfy different tastes, with highlights like swordfish with rice pilaf and chicken croquettes.

  • The staff, including servers like Eric, Logan, and Lauren, go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience for guests.

  • Patrons commend the welcoming ambiance, attentive staff, and flavorful drinks like the S&S Barrel Aged Old Fashioned.

Spoke & Steele

4.2514 reviews
123 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States

Spoke & Steele is a renowned New American restaurant located in Indianapolis, offering a variety of services to cater to different preferences. The restaurant provides options for Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, ensuring that customers can enjoy their meals however they please. Known for its Fast service, Fireplace, Great coffee, and Great dessert, Spoke & Steele creates a cozy and welcoming atmosphere for its patrons.

Customer reviews highlight the exceptional service and delicious food at Spoke & Steele. Some key points from the reviews include:

With a rating of 4.2 and numerous positive reviews, Spoke & Steele stands out as a go-to destination for quality dining in Indianapolis. Visit their website for more information and treat yourself to a memorable culinary experience.

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant, Chicago#16
What sets it apart
  • Customers feel like family due to the friendly and helpful staff.

  • Delicious food and exceptional service are highlighted.

  • Generous portion sizes satisfy every craving.

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

4.12,597 reviews
35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant is a popular Italian restaurant located in Indianapolis. Offering a variety of dining options such as Lunch, Dinner, Catering, and Desserts, this restaurant is known for its fast service and great desserts. Customers love the cozy and trendy atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for families, groups, and even dates.

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Arlington, Chicago#17
What sets it apart
  • Small servings and cold mashed potatoes

  • Outdated restaurant with inconsistent service and food availability

  • Great customer service with special mention of the manager's assistance

  • Improvement in food quality noticed by long-time customers

  • Respectful and quiet ambiance perfect for group settings

  • Decent sides but disappointing main dishes

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Arlington

4.11,090 reviews
6010 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46219, United States

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Arlington offers a wide range of services to cater to different customer needs. Whether you prefer delivery, takeaway, or dine-in, they have you covered. The restaurant is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, making it a versatile choice for various occasions. With amenities like free parking lot and a cosy atmosphere, customers can enjoy a pleasant dining experience.

Overall, MCL Restaurant & Bakery Arlington strives to provide a welcoming atmosphere combined with a diverse menu to ensure customer satisfaction.

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant, Chicago#18
What sets it apart
  • One customer highlighted the fun and value-packed experience of dining here, particularly praising the flavorful dishes and generous portions.

  • Another visitor expressed disappointment with their recent visit, citing chewy calamari and subpar chicken in their pasta dish.

  • A pleased first-time patron commended the large portion sizes, friendly server, and delectable food, promising to return for more.

  • Another satisfied guest mentioned the enjoyable family atmosphere, massive portions, and lively ambiance as standout features of this Italian restaurant.

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

4.01,520 reviews
6045 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant is a renowned spot for authentic Italian cuisine in Indianapolis. Offering a variety of service options including Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, and Dine-in, this restaurant caters to all dining preferences. The highlights of this establishment are its fast service and great dessert options, making it a popular choice for both lunch and dinner.

With a solid rating of 4.0 stars, this spot is highly recommended for those craving a memorable Italian dining experience. If you're in the mood for classic Italian flavors in a lively setting, Buca di Beppo is the place to be.

1913 Restaurant, Chicago#19
What sets it apart
  • Customers appreciated the small omelette station and the atmosphere.

  • However, some mentioned that the food quality did not match the high cost.

  • Others expressed dissatisfaction with the limited food options and service quality.

1913 Restaurant

4.062 reviews
40 W Jackson Pl, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States

1913 Restaurant is an American restaurant located in Indianapolis. They offer a variety of services such as takeaway, dine-in, and they are also known for their fast service, great coffee, and great dessert. With a rating of 4.0, they have garnered positive reviews from customers.

If you are looking for a cozy and trendy spot to enjoy a meal, 1913 Restaurant is worth checking out!

Chicago fish and chicken#20
What sets it apart
  • Customers appreciate the fresh and hot food but some have experienced missing items in their order.

  • Many rave about the incredible and delicious food options on the menu, praising the gyro platter, wings, and Philly steak sandwich.

  • Some have mentioned issues with cold food and poor customer service, impacting their overall experience.

  • Others have highlighted the excellent customer service and quick service, especially when dining in their car.

Chicago fish and chicken

4.0517 reviews
5602 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241, United States

Chicago fish and chicken is a popular American restaurant located in Indianapolis. They offer a variety of service options such as delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. The restaurant is known for being popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Customers can enjoy comfort food, late-night food, quick bites, and small plates at this establishment. The atmosphere is described as casual and trendy, making it a great spot for groups.

Chicago Fish and Chicken Gyro#21
What sets it apart
  • Customers appreciate the delicious food options, with favorites like the chicken tenders and cheeseburger

  • Some reviews mention small hiccups in orders, like onions in a gyro that was supposed to be plain, but overall, the food is described as warm and flavorful

  • Many customers praise the friendly staff and quick service, with one reviewer noting that orders are usually ready in just 15 minutes

Chicago Fish and Chicken Gyro

4.0229 reviews
9942 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229, United States

Chicago Fish and Chicken Gyro is a popular chicken restaurant located in Indianapolis, offering a variety of options to satisfy your cravings. Customers can enjoy delivery or takeaway service and indulge in the comfort food and late-night food offerings available.

Experience the casual atmosphere and diverse menu at Chicago Fish and Chicken Gyro for a satisfying dining experience.

The comparison in brief

Is your business listed here?

Claim or add my business

Map of Restaurants between Chicago and Indianapolis

Embark on a culinary adventure between Chicago and Indianapolis with this interactive map showcasing all the restaurants along the way. Whether you're craving deep dish pizza, barbecue ribs, or farm-to-table fare, this map has you covered. Plan your pit stops and indulge in delicious dining options as you travel through the heartland. Bon appétit!

Tips for choosing restaurants between and indianapolis in Chicago

  1. Varied cuisines to choose from.
  2. Location and proximity to major highways.
  3. Ambiance and atmosphere.
  4. Prices and value for money.
  5. Customer reviews and ratings.

More guides like this