Menu

The 15 Best Pumpkin Pie in Chicago

Looking for the best pumpkin pie in Chicago? Look no further! Whether you're a local or just passing through, there are plenty of delicious options to satisfy your pumpkin pie cravings in the Windy City.

From traditional bakeries to trendy cafes, the diverse array of choices can make it difficult to decide where to indulge in this classic fall treat. That's where this list comes in handy - providing you with the ultimate guide to the top pumpkin pies in Chicago.

Get ready to discover the best pumpkin pie Chicago has to offer!

The Best Pumpkin Pie in Chicago:

How this ranking works

The order here is based on merit: a business that focuses on this work and has a solid reputation ranks above one that only offers it on the side.

Some businesses pay for a fuller profile or a featured position. It is only open to those that have already passed our selection, and it is always marked.

Top 3Full rankingMapTips for choosing

Our 15 local picks compared

Pie, Pie My Darling, Chicago#1
What sets it apart
  • The variety of flavors is outstanding, with each one surpassing expectations, even for non-vegan eaters.

  • The hazelnut chocolate cake is highlighted as one of the best vegan cakes ever tasted, rich, creamy, and flavorful.

  • Affordability is also appreciated, with customers noting the reasonable prices for such high-quality desserts.

  • The owner's talent in creating unique and delicious vegan cakes is commended and recommended for any celebration.

Pie, Pie My Darling

4.8204 reviews
2636 W Chicago Ave Suite 1, Chicago, IL 60622, United States

Pie, Pie My Darling is a renowned bakery in Chicago that offers a wide array of delicious vegan desserts. Customers rave about the amazing flavors and quality of the cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and other treats available. The owner, Heather, is praised for her dedication and creativity in crafting these delectable delights. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

If you're in the mood for decadent vegan sweets, Pie, Pie My Darling is the place to visit!

First Slice Pie Cafe, Chicago#2
What sets it apart
  • Cute cheesecakes and fresh pies

  • Reasonable prices and friendly staff

  • Delicious polka dot cheesecake and mango margarita pie

  • Great place for lunch with a variety of tasty offerings

First Slice Pie Cafe

4.7785 reviews
5357 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60640, United States

First Slice Pie Cafe is a charming pie shop located in Chicago, IL. They offer a variety of services such as delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and dine-in options. The cafe is also wheelchair-accessible with a quick visit planning option available.

Customers rave about their experience at First Slice Pie Cafe with a remarkable rating of 4.7.

With a focus on providing excellent pies and a welcoming atmosphere, First Slice Pie Cafe has quickly become a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike.

First Slice Pie Cafe Manor, Chicago#3
What sets it apart
  • Delicious mango margarita cheesecake pie and broccoli cheddar quiche

  • French silk pie and zesty Cuban sandwich are must-try items

  • Wonderful apple pie but management could improve wait times

  • Decently priced pies and great atmosphere by the train

First Slice Pie Cafe Manor

4.7226 reviews
4664 N Manor Ave, Chicago, IL 60625, United States

First Slice Pie Cafe Manor offers a variety of service options to cater to different preferences, including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. With highlights like great coffee, great dessert, and a great tea selection, this cafe is sure to please any palate. It is also popular for breakfast, lunch, solo dining, and as a great spot for working on a laptop.

Customers have shared their experiences, highlighting a few key points:

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits, Chicago#4
What sets it apart
  • Absolutely loved the pies, both savory and sweet. The chocolate milkshake pie was a hit!

  • The outdoor space is cute and perfect for warm weather. The chicken pot pie was delicious.

  • The savory smothered biscuit with pimento cheese was delightful and had great flavors.

  • The hot coffee was a delight and perfect for a self-care day or a date.

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits

4.61,561 reviews
2051 N California Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, United States

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits is a charming pie shop located in Chicago. They offer a variety of services such as delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers have praised their delicious pies and biscuits, highlighting the flaky pastry and great fillings.

Customers have praised the friendly service, cute decor, and great prices at Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits. If you're in the mood for some mouth-watering pies and biscuits, this place is definitely worth a visit!

Hoosier Mama Pie Company, Chicago#5
What sets it apart
  • The Passionfruit Meringue pie and Coconut Cream pie are both amazing, with flavorful and light fillings.

  • The pie flight, consisting of chocolate cream, matcha custard, and passion fruit pies, is a must-try and incredibly delicious.

  • The match pie and biscuits and gravy are exceptional, while the coconut cream and chocolate cream pies are good but could use a bit more flavor.

  • The savory pies, quiches, and latte art are top-notch, with standout items like the tomatillo pie and fluffy, moist quiches.

Hoosier Mama Pie Company

4.6682 reviews
1618 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60622, United States

Hoosier Mama Pie Company is a beloved pie shop located in Chicago, IL. The shop offers a variety of services and features to its customers, such as in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, takeaway, and breakfast dining options. The shop is also LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender safe space, creating a welcoming environment for all.

Customers rave about the delicious pies and pastries at Hoosier Mama Pie Company. Some key points from their reviews include:

With a rating of 4.6 and glowing reviews from customers like these, Hoosier Mama Pie Company is a must-visit for pie lovers in Chicago.

Barangaroos Aussie Pies, Chicago#6
What sets it apart
  • The pies are delicious with a flaky buttery crust and flavorful fillings.

  • Great variety of options like lamb curry, Guinness beef, and chicken tikka masala.

  • Customers appreciate the convenient service options like delivery, takeaway, and dine-in.

  • Overall, highly recommended for a taste of authentic Australian hand pies.

Barangaroos Aussie Pies

4.6187 reviews
3208 N Sheffield Ave, Chicago, IL 60657, United States

Barangaroos Aussie Pies is a renowned Australian restaurant located in Chicago, IL. They offer a variety of delicious hand-sized pies that customers rave about. The restaurant provides different service options such as delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, making it convenient for everyone.

Customers love the flaky butter crust of the pies, describing it as almost like a croissant. The savory fillings like lamb curry, Guinness beef, chicken tikka masala, and more are highly praised for their taste and authenticity.

Here are some key points summarizing customer reviews:

For those looking to experience traditional Australian cuisine in a cozy and casual atmosphere, Barangaroos Aussie Pies is the place to visit.

Roeser's Bakery, Chicago#7
What sets it apart
  • Fresh and delicious pastries and donuts

  • Exceptional customer service with friendly and helpful staff

  • High-quality cakes that are soft, fresh, and flavorful

  • A longstanding reputation for being the best bakery in Chicago

Roeser's Bakery

4.51,960 reviews
3216 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, United States

Roeser's Bakery is a beloved establishment in Chicago offering a variety of fresh baked goods. Customers can enjoy the convenience of delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway options. The bakery prides itself on providing quick visits and offers various payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and SNAP/EBT. Additionally, customers can revel in the convenience of free parking.

With a high rating of 4.5, based on 1960 reviews, it's evident that Roeser's Bakery has a lot to offer. Customers have left glowing reviews about their experiences, highlighting key points such as:

These positive reviews underscore the bakery's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Justice of the Pies, Chicago#8
What sets it apart
  • Warm welcome and detailed menu description

  • Delicious peach pie with caramel

  • Great service, lovely atmosphere, and amazing food

  • Beautiful space, fantastic cookies, and tasty cinnamon roll

Justice of the Pies

4.680 reviews
8655 S Blackstone Ave, Chicago, IL 60619, United States

Justice of the Pies is a charming bakery located in Chicago that offers a variety of delectable treats. Customers can enjoy services like delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. The cozy atmosphere and top-notch customer service make it a delightful place to visit.

The reviews speak for themselves:

Customers praise the bakery for its unique offerings and the friendly staff. Whether you're a fan of sweet or savory treats, Justice of the Pies is sure to satisfy your cravings.

Honeypie Bakeshop, Chicago#9
What sets it apart
  • The peach/blackberry pie had nice fruit chunks but was overly lemony, suggesting a need to balance flavors.

  • One customer enjoyed the sweet and acidic cherry pie, noting its good crust and appreciating the late opening hours.

  • Another reviewer described the shop as a chill dessert bar with perfectly balanced pies and great customer service.

Honeypie Bakeshop

4.677 reviews
6155 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60660, United States

Honeypie Bakeshop is a charming pie shop located in Chicago, Illinois. The shop offers a variety of delicious pies that are both beautifully decorated and bursting with flavors. Customers have praised the shop for its exceptional customer service and high-quality desserts.

With service options like in-store pick-up and takeaway, and accessible features like a wheelchair-accessible entrance, Honeypie Bakeshop is a must-visit for pie lovers looking for a delightful treat in a cozy atmosphere. Stop by for a slice of pie or two, and experience the sweetness for yourself!

Pies Of London, Chicago#10
What sets it apart
  • Customers appreciate the flavorful pies and quality ingredients.

  • Many enjoy the flaky crusts and satisfying fillings that make each bite heavenly.

  • People also love the friendly service and careful packaging for delivery orders.

Pies Of London

4.819 reviews

Open 24 hours

135 N Kedzie Ave, Chicago, IL 60612, United States

Pies Of London is a beloved bakery in Chicago, known for its delectable pies made with top-quality ingredients. With a stellar rating of 4.8, it's no surprise that customers rave about their offerings.

Whether you're in the mood for a savory treat like a sausage roll or a sweet indulgence like a chocolate chip cookie, Pies Of London has something to satisfy your cravings. Don't miss out on these delightful pies that will transport you to the bustling streets of London with each bite!

First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose, Chicago#11
What sets it apart
  • Warm and cozy lunch spot with a wide array of food options

  • Authentic American experience with hand-made pies and excellent service

  • Great selection of pies, sandwiches, and tamales

  • Top-notch pies and hot drinks

First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose

4.570 reviews
1969 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL 60618, United States

First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose is a charming pie shop located in Chicago, offering a variety of delicious pies, sandwiches, quiches, and more. Customers can enjoy their meal through delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, or dine-in options. The cafe is also wheelchair-accessible, making it inclusive for all visitors.

With a rating of 4.5, based on 70 reviews, First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose has garnered a positive reputation among its patrons. Some key points from customer reviews include:

Whether you're looking for a delicious pie or a hearty sandwich, First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose is a must-visit spot in Chicago. So why not stop by and indulge in some delightful treats?

Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill, Chicago#12
What sets it apart
  • The turkey burger melts in your mouth and is incredibly tasty.

  • The caramel cake is described as moist, soft, and perfectly sweet.

  • The jerk shrimp Alfredo is a must-try dish, while the lemon pound cake is made with love.

  • Customers appreciate the friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere at one of 79th street gems.

Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill

4.587 reviews
7907 S Champlain Ave, Chicago, IL 60619, United States

Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill is a beloved establishment in Chicago that offers a unique culinary experience. With a rating of 4.5 stars, customers rave about the delicious food and exceptional customer service. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

From quick visits to catering events, Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill offers a wide range of services for every occasion. Whether you're looking for delivery, in-store pick-up, or takeout, this bakery has you covered. Visit them today and indulge in their mouthwatering creations.

Pies by Shine, Chicago#13
What sets it apart
  • Pies by Shine excels at creating delectable desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.

  • Customers rave about the quality of the pies, stating that they are the best they have ever tasted.

  • The convenience of ordering from Pies by Shine is highly praised, with many customers eager to place another order soon.

Pies by Shine

5.05 reviews
W 71st St, Chicago, IL 60636, United States

Pies by Shine is a beloved cake shop located in Chicago, IL, known for its exceptional desserts. The business offers a variety of services, including in-store pick-up and takeaway, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their delicious pies. Customers can easily pay with credit or debit cards, providing a seamless transaction experience.

With a 5.0 rating, Pies by Shine has received numerous positive reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points highlighted by reviewers:

Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in these delectable pies! Whether you're a pie enthusiast or looking for a special treat, Pies by Shine is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings. Visit their website or stop by their shop today to experience the magic of their delicious desserts.

Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe, Chicago#14
What sets it apart
  • Excellent pastry shop with delicious treats and incredible coffee. Friendly staff and beautiful decor.

  • Love the ambiance and the mouthwatering pastries, cakes, and beverages. Outdoor seating provides a great experience.

  • Quaint bakery with beautiful cakes and a friendly, organized staff. A must-visit for special occasions.

  • Wide variety of pastries and cakes, perfect for any occasion. The food is delicious and the staff is excellent.

Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe

4.4391 reviews
1114 W Belmont Ave, Chicago, IL 60657, United States

Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe is a delightful pastry shop located in Chicago. They offer a wide range of services and features that cater to every customer's needs. From kerbside pickup and delivery to dine-in and in-store shopping</b, the options are endless. The highlights of this charming spot include their great desserts and a welcoming atmosphere that is LGBTQ+ friendly.

Customers have left glowing reviews for Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe.

Visit Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe to satisfy your sweet cravings and enjoy a memorable experience in the heart of Chicago.

West Town Bakery, Chicago#15
What sets it apart
  • Friendly staff and delicious treats

  • Great variety of pastries and bread

  • Top-notch service and pleasant atmosphere

  • Highly recommended for a delightful bakery experience

West Town Bakery

4.1167 reviews
15 E Ohio St, Chicago, IL 60611, United States

West Town Bakery is a charming Bakery located in Chicago that offers a variety of delectable treats. With options for Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, and Takeaway, customers have the flexibility to enjoy their favorites however they please. The bakery also provides Breakfast options, making it a perfect spot to start your day.

One of the standout features of West Town Bakery is its friendly staff who ensure that every visit is a pleasant experience. Customers rave about the delicious pastries and bread, with special mentions of the chocolate muffin and fluffy donuts. The service is top-notch, and the variety of flavors keeps customers coming back for more.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

If you're in the mood for a sweet treat or a tasty breakfast, West Town Bakery is a must-visit spot that promises to satisfy your cravings with its delightful offerings.

The comparison in brief

Is your business listed here?

Claim or add my business

Map of Pumpkin Pie in Chicago

Chicago is known for its delicious pumpkin pie offerings, with numerous bakeries and restaurants serving up this classic dessert. From traditional recipes to unique twists, pumpkin pie enthusiasts will find a plethora of options to satisfy their sweet tooth in the Windy City. Check out the map below to discover all the best places to indulge in pumpkin pie in Chicago.

Tips for choosing Pumpkin Pie in Chicago

  1. Wide variety of flavors and styles.
  2. Convenient locations throughout the city.

More guides like this