Menu

The 16 Best Pecan Pie in Chicago

For anyone in Chicago with a craving for a delicious slice of pecan pie, look no further! This page is your go-to guide for finding the best pecan pie in the Windy City.

Whether you're a local looking for a new favorite spot or just passing through and in need of a sweet treat, you'll want to check out the list below to compare options and find the perfect pie for you.

Take a look at the top 16 places to enjoy pecan pie in Chicago and satisfy your sweet tooth!

How this guide is ordered

This list comes from our Chicago editors, who looked citywide for businesses with a long record of satisfied customers, details we could verify and dependable work through every season. We revisit it regularly, so let us know if something has changed.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Compare 16 local options

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits#1
What stands out
  • Absolutely loved the pies! Both savory and sweet options were delicious. Quick and sweet service with a lovely outdoor vibe. Sold out items might still be available if asked.

  • While the line was long, the experience was worth it. Great outdoor space and delicious chicken pot pie. A place to come back to.

  • The biscuits were light and fluffy, the toppings delicious. Great for a light breakfast or lunch.

  • The chocolate pudding pie was a delight with perfect consistencies and not overly sweet. Looking forward to trying more pies in the future.

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits

4.61,561 reviews
2051 N California Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, United States

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits is a renowned pie shop located in Chicago, IL. The business offers a variety of services including Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Customers can enjoy their delicious pies in a charming atmosphere with amenities like Wi-Fi and quick visit options. The business accepts various payment methods for convenience. Parking is also available with free street parking.

With a rating of 4.6 out of 5, based on 1561 reviews, Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits has received praise from satisfied customers. Their savory and sweet pies have been highlighted for their delicious flavors and flaky crusts. The quick and sweet service and lovely outdoor seating have also been mentioned positively by patrons.

First Slice Pie Cafe#2
What stands out
  • Cute cheesecakes and fresh pies

  • Reasonable prices

  • Great neighborhood spot

  • Excellent cherry pie and friendly service

First Slice Pie Cafe

4.7785 reviews
5357 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60640, United States

First Slice Pie Cafe is a beloved pie shop in Chicago that offers a variety of delicious pies and desserts. Customers rave about the cute cheesecakes, fresh pies, and friendly staff. The cafe provides multiple service options such as delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and dine-in. They also have a wheelchair-accessible entrance for the convenience of all customers.

Some of the key points from customer reviews include:

With a solid rating of 4.7, First Slice Pie Cafe is a go-to spot for pie lovers looking for delicious treats in a welcoming environment. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or planning a leisurely visit, this cafe has something for everyone.

Roeser's Bakery#3
What stands out
  • Customers rave about the variety of pastries and cakes available.

  • The quality of the baked goods is consistently excellent.

  • The staff is friendly and provides top-notch customer service.

  • The bakery offers convenient service options like delivery and pick-up.

Roeser's Bakery

4.51,960 reviews
3216 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, United States

Roeser's Bakery is a beloved establishment in Chicago offering a wide array of baked goods and treats. Their service options include delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Customers praise the bakery for its delicious pastries and friendly atmosphere.

Whether you're in the mood for a sweet treat or need a custom cake for a special occasion, Roeser's Bakery has you covered. Visit their website or stop by their location on West North Ave to satisfy your cravings for freshly baked goods.

Panaderia Nuevo Leon#4
What stands out
  • Delicious and fresh pastries, with a great selection of vegan options

  • Beautifully decorated bakery with friendly and quick service

  • Affordable pricing and a wide variety of baked goods to choose from

Panaderia Nuevo Leon

4.6834 reviews
1634 W 18th St, Chicago, IL 60608, United States

Panaderia Nuevo Leon is a beloved bakery located in the heart of Chicago, offering a wide range of delicious treats from traditional Mexican pastries to vegan options. The bakery provides service options like takeaway and accepts credit cards and NFC mobile payments for customer convenience.

Customers rave about their experience at Panaderia Nuevo Leon, here are some key points from their reviews:

With a rating of 4.6 based on 834 reviews, it's no surprise that Panaderia Nuevo Leon is a must-visit spot for pastry lovers in Chicago. Plan a quick visit to enjoy the authentic Mexican flavors and welcoming atmosphere of this local gem.

Hoosier Mama Pie Company#5
What stands out
  • The Passionfruit Meringue and Coconut Cream pies were described as both amazing with unique flavors

  • The variety of pies available, including the Chocolate Cream, Matcha Custard, and Passionfruit pies, were all very delicious

  • The biscuits and gravy and match pie were highlighted as must-try items

  • Customers appreciated the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere of the shop

Hoosier Mama Pie Company

4.6682 reviews
1618 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60622, United States

Hoosier Mama Pie Company is a beloved pie shop located in Chicago, offering an array of delicious pies and pastries. The business provides various services like in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway options for convenience. Customers have praised the wheelchair-accessible entrance and the LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere at the shop.

Some of the popular pies include the Passionfruit Meringue, Coconut Cream, and Chocolate Cream pies. Customers have mentioned in their reviews the exquisite flavors and perfect balance of these desserts. The shop also serves savory options like the sausage-parmesan hand pie and delicious quiches.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Visit Hoosier Mama Pie Company to indulge in delectable pies and enjoy a cozy atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more.

Pie, Pie My Darling#6
What stands out
  • The owner, Heather, crafts an array of cake flavors that have customers coming back for more.

  • From rotating menus of cupcakes to featured cake slices, every flavor is outstanding and memorable.

  • Non-vegan friends have been blown away by the taste and quality, proving that vegan desserts can rival traditional ones.

Pie, Pie My Darling

4.8204 reviews
2636 W Chicago Ave Suite 1, Chicago, IL 60622, United States

Pie, Pie My Darling bakery located in Chicago is a haven for vegans and non-vegans alike. Their Service options include in-store pick-up and takeaway, ensuring customers can enjoy their delectable treats with ease. Accessibility is also prioritized with a wheelchair-accessible entrance. Customers rave about the quick visit experience, where they can pop in and indulge in the finest vegan desserts in town.

Don't miss out on their hazelnut chocolate cake or the chocolate hazelnut cake for an unforgettable vegan dessert experience. Visit Pie, Pie My Darling bakery for a taste of perfection in every bite.

Letizia's Natural Bakery#7
What stands out
  • Great bakery and coffee cafe with cozy Italian vibes

  • Delicious cookies and pastries made in-house

  • Unique panini, soup, and bagel options

  • Charming rustic atmosphere and a lovely backyard patio

Letizia's Natural Bakery

4.5342 reviews
2144 W Division St, Chicago, IL 60622, United States

Letizia's Natural Bakery is a cozy Italian-inspired bakery located in Chicago. They offer a variety of delicious pastries, cookies, soup, panini, and bagels with unique toppings. The atmosphere at Letizia's is rustic, with a warm and welcoming feel. Customers love the homemade baked goods and the cozy backyard patio where they can enjoy their food.

Barangaroos Aussie Pies#8
What stands out
  • Flaky buttery crust and phenomenal taste of pies.

  • Extremely flavorful sausage rolls and great service.

  • Delicious savory hand-sized pies with unique flavors.

  • Authentic Australian food, professional service, and delicious pies.

Barangaroos Aussie Pies

4.6187 reviews
3208 N Sheffield Ave, Chicago, IL 60657, United States

Barangaroos Aussie Pies offers a delightful experience for those looking to savor authentic Australian flavors. With a rating of 4.6, it's clear that customers are raving about the culinary offerings at this Australian restaurant in Chicago. The Service options include Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, catering to various preferences.

Customers have left glowing reviews, highlighting the following key points:

Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite, a comforting meal, or a delightful dining experience, Barangaroos Aussie Pies is the place to be. Don't miss out on the chance to indulge in these delectable offerings!

Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe#9
What stands out
  • Delicious pastries and bakery items

  • Beautifully decorated shop with quick and friendly staff

  • Specialty cakes that are both stunning and tasty

Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe

4.4391 reviews
1114 W Belmont Ave, Chicago, IL 60657, United States

Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe is a charming pastry shop located in Chicago that offers a variety of service options such as kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, takeaway, and dine-in. The shop is known for its great desserts and is wheelchair-accessible, making it inclusive for all visitors. Whether you're looking for a quick visit or a leisurely meal, Bittersweet has something for everyone.

Customers rave about their experience at Bittersweet, highlighting the following key points:

With a rating of 4.4 stars and glowing reviews, it's no wonder why Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Stop by to indulge in their delectable treats and enjoy the cozy atmosphere!

Honeypie Bakeshop#10
What stands out
  • The pies are beautifully decorated, but the slices can be small for the price.

  • Customers love the cherry pie's sweetness and slight acidity, plus the shop's late opening hours.

  • One visitor enjoyed the balanced flavors of the pie and the friendly customer service.

  • Another patron raved about the delicious desserts, especially the Brownie and Snickerdoodle treats.

Honeypie Bakeshop

4.677 reviews
6155 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60660, United States

Honeypie Bakeshop is a delightful pie shop in Chicago offering a variety of beautifully decorated pies with interesting flavors. Customers can enjoy in-store pick-up or takeaway options. The shop is wheelchair-accessible and perfect for a quick visit.

With a commendable rating of 4.6 based on 77 reviews, customers have shared their experiences:

Visit Honeypie Bakeshop for a chill dessert experience with a great balance of flavors and exceptional customer service!

Pies Of London#11
What stands out
  • Delicious pies made with quality ingredients.

  • Perfect balance of sweet and savory flavors.

  • Flaky and buttery crust that melts in your mouth.

  • Excellent customer service and attention to detail.

Pies Of London

4.819 reviews
135 N Kedzie Ave, Chicago, IL 60612, United States

Pies Of London is a renowned Bakery located in Chicago that offers a variety of delectable pies made with the finest ingredients. Customers rave about the quality and taste of the pies, describing them as flavorful and satisfying. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Whether you're craving a savory meat pie or a sweet treat, Pies Of London is the go-to place for pie lovers. The bakery also offers delivery and takeaway options for added convenience. Don't miss out on the chance to indulge in these mouth-watering pies!

Pies by Shine#12
What stands out
  • Pies by Shine creates stellar desserts that are perfect for any occasion.

  • Customers can't get enough of the Lemon pie, which is a fan favorite.

  • Pie lovers will appreciate the convenience of ordering from Pies by Shine and skipping the supermarket.

Pies by Shine

5.05 reviews
W 71st St, Chicago, IL 60636, United States

Pies by Shine is a top-tier cake shop located in Chicago. They offer a variety of delectable pies and desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet craving. Customers rave about the quality of the pies and the excellent service provided by the staff.

Whether you're looking for a quick treat or planning a special event, Pies by Shine has you covered. Their service options include in-store pick-up and takeaway, making it easy to enjoy their delicious pies. Additionally, they accept credit cards and debit cards for payment, adding to the convenience of ordering from them. Visit their website to place an order and experience the magic of Pies by Shine for yourself.

Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill#13
What stands out
  • Home-cooked flavors with a twist, finger-licking good

  • Scrumptious dishes like the Jerk Shrimp Alfredo and Chicken Florentine Pasta

  • Generous portions, friendly staff, and love put into each dish

Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill

4.587 reviews
7907 S Champlain Ave, Chicago, IL 60619, United States

Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill is a beloved bakery in Chicago that offers a wide range of delectable treats. From mouth-watering Turkey Burger to Caramel Cake, customers rave about the home-cooked flavors with a twist. The Jerk Shrimp Alfredo is a definite hit, while the Chicken Florentine Pasta promises to be a must-try. The bakery also caters to events, ensuring a scrumptious experience for all attendees. With an average rating of 4.5 stars, patrons praise the generous portions, friendly staff, and the overall love and effort put into each dish. If you're looking for a slice of goodness, Pie Guys Bakery is the place to be!

Royal Pies#14

Royal Pies

5.04 reviews
2119 S Halsted St, Chicago, IL 60608, United States

Royal Pies offers a delightful array of pies that have customers raving about their quality and taste. With a perfect rating of 5.0 stars, this bakery stands out for its excellence. Customers praise the light and flaky crusts and scrumptious fillings, with special mention to the vegan options that are said to be "to die for." Royal Pies also offers savory options, like the steak and ale meat pie, which are described as outstanding. The service is great, and customers appreciate the swift and quick visit experience. Payment is hassle-free with credit cards accepted. If you find yourself in Chicago, don't miss the chance to try these delectable pies at Royal Pies.

First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose#15
What stands out
  • Warm and cozy lunch spot with a friendly and knowledgeable staff

  • Delicious hand-made pies and generous sandwich servings

  • Great addition to the area with amazing food variety

  • Top-notch pies and hot drinks always

First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose

4.570 reviews
1969 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL 60618, United States

First Slice Pie Cafe Montrose offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere for customers to enjoy a wide array of pies, sandwiches, quiches, and more. The cafe provides delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers have highlighted the following key points in their reviews:

Tonya's Slice of Heaven#16
What stands out
  • Absolutely delicious and beautiful pies

  • Reliably delivered early and on budget

  • Tonya is a warm woman who has found her calling in making delicious pies

  • Menu options include a wide range of flavors to satisfy any craving

Tonya's Slice of Heaven

5.01 reviews
7331 N Sheridan Rd, Chicago, IL 60626, United States

Tonya's Slice of Heaven is a charming pie shop located in Chicago, IL. The shop offers a variety of mouthwatering pies for takeaway with the convenience of credit card payments. Customers have raved about the delicious and beautiful pies created by Tonya, describing them as reliable, budget-friendly, and absolutely scrumptious.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

With a perfect rating of 5.0 stars, Tonya's Slice of Heaven is a must-visit for pie lovers looking for a sweet treat that is sure to impress.

The comparison at a glance

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map of Pecan Pie in Chicago

Looking for the best places to enjoy a slice of delectable pecan pie in Chicago? Look no further! This map showcases all the top spots in the city where you can indulge in this delicious Southern treat. Whether you're a local or just visiting, be sure to check out these amazing locations for a taste of pure indulgence.

How to choose Pecan Pie in Chicago

  1. Locations across the city.
  2. Online ordering available.
  3. Variety of topping and crust options.
  4. Featured on local "Best Of" lists.

Related guides