Menu

The 16 Best NY Style Pizza in Chicago

For those craving a taste of the Big Apple in the Windy City, look no further than NY style pizza in Chicago. With its thin crust, foldable slices, and generous toppings, this East Coast favorite has found a home in the heart of the Midwest. Whether you're a native New Yorker or just a pizza aficionado, these Chicago establishments serve up the real deal.

From classic slices to gourmet toppings, there are plenty of options to satisfy your cravings for NY style pizza in Chicago. Check out the list below for the best spots in the city to grab a true taste of New York.

How this ranking works

This guide does not try to list everyone. It is our pick of NY style pizza in Chicago, built on each business's public reputation and on how central this service is to what it does.

Some businesses pay for a fuller profile or a featured position. It is only open to those that have already passed our selection, and it is always marked.

Top 3Full rankingMapTips for choosing

Our 16 local picks compared

Proper Pizza Chicago#1
What sets it apart
  • Amazing experience with the manager who guided through options and made the visit exceptional.

  • Generous slice size for the cost and flavorful cheese pizza.

  • High standards of pizza comparable to New York.

  • Warm and inviting atmosphere with quality ingredients and unique flavors.

Proper Pizza Chicago

4.7298 reviews
2459 N Halsted St, Chicago, IL 60614, United States

Proper Pizza Chicago is a beloved Pizza restaurant in Chicago that offers a variety of service options including Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Customers love the fast service and the atmosphere, describing it as casual and trendy. The restaurant is family-friendly and LGBTQ+ friendly, making it a welcoming place for all.

Max and Issy's Pizzeria, Chicago#2
What sets it apart
  • Customers love the unique pizzas like the Queen of Hearts and the hot honey pepper pizza

  • Great atmosphere for a date night or casual hangout with friends

  • Generous portions mean plenty of leftovers to enjoy later

Max and Issy's Pizzeria

4.6606 reviews
1028 W Diversey Pkwy, Chicago, IL 60614, United States

Max and Issy's Pizzeria is a beloved pizza restaurant in Chicago known for its delicious pies and welcoming atmosphere. With a rating of 4.6 out of 5, this spot is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Customers rave about the fast service and cozy atmosphere that make every visit a memorable experience.

The decor is described as gorgeous and the staff as super friendly, creating a special dining experience for all who walk through the door. If you're in the mood for Italian style thin crust pizza and a great selection of beer and cocktails, be sure to check out Max and Issy's Pizzeria!

Giordano's, Chicago#3
What sets it apart
  • This is the only place these customers tried deep-dish pizza in Chicago, and they found it rich, flavorful, and worth the wait. Highly recommended for an authentic deep-dish experience.

  • Despite not being a fan of deep-dish, another customer acknowledged the great service and the packed venue, suggesting sticking with thin crust. The calamari was particularly notable.

  • While appreciating the lively atmosphere and service, a patron was disappointed in the lack of texture and flavor in the deep-dish pizza they waited an hour for.

  • A customer had a fantastic experience with exemplary servers, fantastic drinks, and delicious appetizers while complimenting Giordano's as the best deep-dish in Chicago.

Giordano's

4.517,201 reviews
130 E Randolph St, Chicago, IL 60601, United States

Giordano's is a renowned pizza delivery spot located in Chicago, IL. This restaurant offers a variety of service options including delivery, dine-in, takeaway, and ensuring kerbside pickup and no-contact delivery for a safe and convenient experience. The establishment is also accessible to all with wheelchair-accessible car park, entrance, seating, and toilet. Customers can pay with ease using credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments while taking advantage of the available paid street parking.

With a notable rating of 4.5 stars, their reputation precedes them. Here are a few noteworthy reviews from patrons:

These reviews showcase the diverse experiences customers have at Giordano's, proving its place as a beloved pizza destination in the heart of Chicago.

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria, Chicago#4
What sets it apart
  • Deep-dish pizzas are always amazing here.

  • The gluten-free pizzas are a hit, and the staff is extremely friendly.

  • Chicago-style pizza done right with a sweet, chunky tomato sauce and crunchy crust.

  • Highly recommend making reservations to save waiting time and try other menu options apart from just pizza.

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

4.58,029 reviews
805 S State St, Chicago, IL 60605, United States

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria is an iconic pizza delivery spot located in Chicago. Offering a variety of service options like no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, this place ensures customers can enjoy their favorite pizzas however they prefer. The accessibility features including a wheelchair-accessible entrance, seating, and toilet make it inclusive for all. Customers can pay using credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

This pizzeria is known for its amazing deep-dish and thin-crust pizzas that keep customers coming back for more. With a rating of 4.5 based on 8029 reviews, it's evident that Lou Malnati's Pizzeria is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Jimmy's Pizza Cafe, Chicago#5
What sets it apart
  • Delicious and unique pizza slices that are filling

  • Great dine-in and delivery experiences with consistently good food

  • Spacious setting with a suburban feel, perfect for trying out a variety of pizza options

  • Amazing thin crust NY style pizza with a variety of topping combinations that are perfect

Jimmy's Pizza Cafe

4.51,355 reviews
2434 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL 60618, United States

Jimmy's Pizza Cafe is a popular restaurant located in Chicago that offers a variety of services and highlights for its customers. This cozy cafe is known for its fast service, fireplace, great beer selection, great coffee, and creates a casual, cosy, and trendy atmosphere for diners. Customers can enjoy delivery, takeaway, or dine-in options along with wheelchair-accessible entrance, seating, and toilets. For those with kids, high chairs are available as well.

Some of the key points from customer reviews include:

Paulie Gee's Logan Square, Chicago#6
What sets it apart
  • The Detroit style pizza with a Parmesan crust is a must-try

  • Great options for both vegan and non-vegan customers

  • Super friendly and attentive staff

  • Insane flavors and a chill dining experience

Paulie Gee's Logan Square

4.51,325 reviews
2451 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, United States

Paulie Gee's Logan Square is a renowned pizza restaurant in Chicago that offers a variety of service options such as delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy fast service in a casual, cosy, and trendy atmosphere.

Known for their Detroit style pizza, customers rave about the quality of the pizza dough and fresh tomato sauce. The menu also includes halal and vegan options for all the meats, making it a favorite for those with dietary restrictions.

Customer reviews highlight the following key points:

With a rating of 4.5 based on 1325 reviews, Paulie Gee's Logan Square continues to impress both locals and tourists alike. Don't miss out on a truly unique pizza experience at this gem in the heart of Chicago!

Big G's Pizza, Chicago#7
What sets it apart
  • Unique and unforgettable pizza experience with options like Mac n Cheese pizza and Philly Cheese Steak pizza.

  • Delicious and crispy crust with a variety of tasty toppings.

  • Great customer service and friendly staff assisting in selecting the perfect slice or whole pizza.

Big G's Pizza

4.5379 reviews
3716 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60613, United States

Big G's Pizza is a renowned Pizza restaurant located in Chicago that offers a variety of service options like No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. It is popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, with offerings ranging from Comfort food to Late-night food and Vegetarian options.

Customers have lauded this establishment in their reviews, with some key points highlighted:

The 4.5 rating given by patrons speaks volumes about the quality and taste of the pizza served at Big G's Pizza. If you are in the mood for some flavorful and exceptional pizzas, this is the place to be!

Panino's Pizza, Chicago#8
What sets it apart
  • Seriously, they have an amazing wood fire pizza! The margarita with soppressata is a must-try.

  • The Chicken Vesuvio is straight up fire and the staff remembers your preferences for added convenience.

  • Despite exclusive patronage for years, a disappointing experience was shared by a customer regarding a failed order.

  • Every dish at Panino's is consistently delicious, from pizzas to soups and salads.

Panino's Pizza

4.5374 reviews
3702 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60613, United States

Panino's Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant located in the heart of Chicago. The establishment prides itself on offering a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy the highlights of fast service while indulging in popular lunch and dinner options. The restaurant is considered family-friendly and LGBTQ+ friendly, ensuring a welcoming atmosphere for all diners.

Pequod's Pizza, Chicago#9
What sets it apart
  • A visitor praised the pizza for its thick, fluffy crust, sweet and spicy sauce, generous cheese, and exceptional pepperoni. The cozy atmosphere and excellent service added to the overall dining experience.

  • Another customer enjoyed the lively atmosphere and friendly service but found the tomato sauce overpowering on their chosen pizza. Despite this, they appreciated the cheesy garlic bread and the overall experience.

  • One reviewer was impressed by the prompt seating, fast service, and friendly staff. They highly recommended trying other menu items besides pizza for a delightful dining experience.

  • A patron marveled at the famous deep-dish pizza, noting its excellent taste and heaviness due to the size of the dough. They recommended trying this iconic dish for a fulfilling meal.

Pequod's Pizza

4.413,220 reviews
2207 N Clybourn Ave, Chicago, IL 60614, United States

Pequod's Pizza is a renowned Pizza restaurant located in Chicago, known for its delicious deep-dish pizza. The establishment offers various service options including No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, catering to the diverse needs of its customers. The restaurant is popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, while providing accessibility with Wheelchair-accessible seating and Wheelchair-accessible entrance.

Customers have raved about their experiences at Pequod's Pizza, with reviews highlighting:

With a Rating of 4.4 based on 13220 Reviews, Pequod's Pizza continues to uphold its reputation for serving some of the best pizza in Chicago, attracting locals and tourists alike. Visit to indulge in a unique pizza experience that promises satisfaction and flavor in every bite.

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria, Chicago#10
What sets it apart
  • A group had a great experience with friendly staff and delicious deep-dish pizza. They highly recommend it.

  • Another customer enjoyed the crispy crust and unique marinara sauce of the pizza, served by a kind waiter.

  • One visitor described the pizza as the best they've ever had, highlighting the thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings.

  • A group praised the service and delicious food, with one pizza taking longer to make, resulting in complimentary items from the restaurant.

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

4.410,590 reviews
439 N Wells St, Chicago, IL 60654, United States

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria in Chicago offers a variety of services and features that make it a top choice for pizza lovers. From Kerbside pickup to No-contact delivery, Takeaway, Dine-in, and even Delivery</b, customers have multiple options to enjoy their delicious pizzas. This pizza restaurant is known for its Great cocktails and sports-themed Atmosphere.

With over 10,000 reviews and a 4.4-star rating, customers are raving about their experiences at Lou Malnati's.

The restaurant is known for its warm and cozy atmosphere and excellent customer service. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Lou Malnati's Pizzeria is a must-visit spot for an authentic Chicago deep-dish pizza experience.

Robert's Pizza and Dough Company, Chicago#11
What sets it apart
  • Phenomenal pizza with great atmosphere and excellent service

  • Delicious pizza and bottomless mimosas during brunch time

  • Fast service, attentive servers, and unique pizza flavors

  • Amazing pizza options, crispy crust, and friendly environment for dogs

Robert's Pizza and Dough Company

4.41,723 reviews
465 N McClurg Ct, Chicago, IL 60611, United States

Robert's Pizza and Dough Company is a popular pizza restaurant in Chicago known for its delicious pizza, fast service, and great atmosphere. Customers rave about the phenomenal pizza options and excellent service. The restaurant offers a variety of service options like outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. It is highly rated with a score of 4.4 out of 5 based on 1723 reviews.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

If you are a pizza lover in Chicago, don't miss out on Robert's Pizza and Dough Company for a memorable dining experience.

Blaze Pizza, Chicago#12
What sets it apart
  • The crust was well cooked and overall loved the combination. The red sauce could be more flavorful.

  • Thanks for being open on NYE!! Pizza was great and satisfied our hunger.

  • Customizing pizzas at Blaze is a hit! They make it how you like it every time!

  • Beautiful dining experience, Fast, Affordable, and Delicious! Friendly employees make it worth coming back!

Blaze Pizza

4.3699 reviews
511 S State St, Chicago, IL 60605, United States

Blaze Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in Chicago, United States. The restaurant is known for its fast service and is a favorite spot for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The atmosphere is described as casual and trendy, catering to groups, tourists, and university students.

Jet's Pizza, Chicago#13
What sets it apart
  • The Detroit pizza is amazing with a chewy texture and crunch.

  • The staff is happy and very pleasant, providing excellent customer service.

  • The pizza is usually decent, warm, and quick, making it a reliable option for a quick bite.

Jet's Pizza

4.2224 reviews
1144 S Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60605, United States

Jet's Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant in Chicago known for its delicious Detroit-style pizza. Customers can enjoy the convenience of delivery or takeaway options. The restaurant is highlighted for its sports theme, making it a great spot for lunch, dinner, or solo dining.

NLocal pick
#14
What sets it apart
  • Great pizza, especially on Tuesdays!

  • Quality food at affordable prices

  • Friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere

  • Consistent and delicious food options

Naples Pizza

4.2402 reviews
4527 S Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60609, United States

Naples Pizza is a beloved pizza restaurant located in Chicago, IL, known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. The menu includes a variety of options for different tastes, such as pizza, burgers, fries, and wings. Customers have praised the affordability of the food, making it a great option for those on a budget. The service options at Naples Pizza include delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, catering to different dining preferences.

Some key points from customer reviews:

Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a cosy meal, or a trendy atmosphere, Naples Pizza has something for everyone. So if you're in the mood for some comfort food or a late-night snack, be sure to check out Naples Pizza for a satisfying dining experience.

New York Halal Pizza, Chicago#15
What sets it apart
  • HIGHLY recommend! The best halal pizza spot you can have in Chicago!!! The pizza is so perfectly made especially when you have it fresh in house. The menu has so much variety as well. The staff are very kind and caring of their customers.

  • Pizza pizza pizza !! That’s how I react when I’m into the store. Amazing taste and great service with good and friendly staff. 5/5 for all rating from me.

  • First time I went to this place. And the pizza pepperoni is so good. You have to go try it!

  • Service was amazing, the staff was great and joyful. The beef burger was one of the best burgers. Thanks for your service guys.

New York Halal Pizza

4.1382 reviews
2262 W Devon Ave, Chicago, IL 60659, United States

New York Halal Pizza is a beloved pizza restaurant located in Chicago, IL. They offer a range of services like Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. The place is particularly popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, and it is known for its halal food and comfort food options. Customers also appreciate the late-night food and quick bite offerings. The atmosphere is described as casual, making it a great spot for various crowds including groups, tourists, and university students.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Naples Pizza, Chicago#16
What sets it apart
  • Customers have noted inconsistencies in pizza quality with complaints of metal in the food and poor customer service.

  • Some customers experienced cold food and disappointing flavors in their orders.

  • Others remarked on the lack of sauce, strange tastes in certain dishes, and overall dissatisfaction with their dining experience.

Naples Pizza

4.0397 reviews
4300 S Western Ave, Chicago, IL 60609, United States

Naples Pizza is a well-known pizza restaurant located in Chicago, IL. They offer a variety of services including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. It is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Accessibility features include wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible seating, and wheelchair-accessible toilet. Customers can enjoy amenities such as clean toilets. The atmosphere is described as casual, cosy, and trendy with a crowd that is family-friendly, accommodating to groups, LGBTQ+ friendly, attractive to tourists, provides a transgender safe space, and appeals to university students.

The comparison in brief

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Proper Pizza Chicago 4.7298
#2Max and Issy's Pizzeria 4.6606
#3Giordano's 4.517,201
#4Lou Malnati's Pizzeria 4.58,029
#5Jimmy's Pizza Cafe 4.51,355
#6Paulie Gee's Logan Square 4.51,325
#7Big G's Pizza 4.5379
#8Panino's Pizza 4.5374
#9Pequod's Pizza 4.413,220
#10Lou Malnati's Pizzeria 4.410,590
#11Robert's Pizza and Dough Company 4.41,723
#12Blaze Pizza 4.3699
#13Jet's Pizza 4.2224
#14Naples Pizza 4.2402
#15New York Halal Pizza 4.1382
#16Naples Pizza 4.0397

Is your business listed here?

Claim or add my business

Map of NY Style Pizza in Chicago

Explore the bustling and diverse pizza scene in Chicago with our comprehensive map of all the NY style pizza hotspots in the city. From traditional thin-crust pies to gourmet toppings, there is something for every pizza lover to enjoy. Use this map to plan your next pizza adventure in the Windy City and discover new favorite spots to indulge in delicious slices.

Tips for choosing NY Style Pizza in Chicago

  1. Authentic thin crust.
  2. Foldable slices.
  3. Generous toppings.
  4. Gourmet options.

More guides like this