The 16 Best Cookies in Chicago

Crumbl - Wicker Park is a popular dessert shop in Chicago that offers a variety of delicious cookies. Customers have given it a high rating of 4.8 stars based on 3018 reviews. Some key points from customer reviews include:

• The cookies sometimes lack consistency and quality compared to other locations.
• Problems with lack of care shown by employees regarding packaging and customer service.
• Issues with orders being incomplete or incorrect, and unaccommodating staff.

Despite these concerns, many customers have also left positive reviews praising the friendly staff, clean store, and the exciting rotating menu that offers new flavors every week. Customers particularly enjoy the large, delicious cookies and the cute packaging. With various service options like delivery and in-store pick-up, as well as convenient parking options, Crumbl - Wicker Park aims to provide a delightful cookie experience for all its visitors.

Crumbl - Michigan Ave is a popular Dessert shop located in Chicago, IL. Customers rave about the delicious cookies and the excellent service provided by the staff. The shop offers various service options like Kerbside pickup, Delivery, In-store pick-up, and Takeaway, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their treats.

Key points from customer reviews:

• The Lucky Charms cookies are a favorite, with a perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness.
• Customers appreciate the helpful staff and the constantly changing cookie flavors.
• Some cookies are described as fantastic, while others may be a bit lackluster.

Whether you're looking for a quick visit or a treat to enjoy at home, Crumbl - Michigan Ave is a must-visit for cookie lovers in the area. Check out their website for more information and to place an order.

Folkmade Custom Cookies is a beloved cookie shop in Chicago that offers a wide range of customizable cookies for any occasion. Customers rave about the delicious taste and stunning designs of the cookies created by Ashley, the talented owner.

• Customers praise the adorable and delicious cookies made by Ashley for special events like birthdays and baptisms.
• Reviewers commend Ashley's responsiveness and collaborative approach to designing cookies that exceed expectations.
• Many customers are impressed by the detail and unique designs of the cookies, along with their freshness that lasts for weeks.
• People appreciate Ashley's professionalism and creativity in bringing their visions to life, making Folkmade their go-to for custom cookie needs.

If you're looking for beautifully crafted and delicious custom cookies for your next event, Folkmade Custom Cookies is the perfect choice. Visit their website to place an order and experience the magic of Ashley's creations!

Crumbl - Old Town is a beloved Dessert shop in Chicago that offers a delightful selection of cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. With an impressive rating of 4.8 stars from 272 reviews, customers rave about the fantastic service and delicious treats they receive.

• Customers are impressed by the fast and friendly service at this location.
• The unique and rotating flavors keep customers coming back for more.
• Visitors appreciate the quality and variety offered in the weekly specialty cookie selection.
• The soft and delicate cookies, alongside the warm and welcoming staff, create an exceptional experience for all.

Whether you're looking for a quick sweet treat or a box of delectable cookies to share, Crumbl - Old Town is the perfect destination for anyone with a love for sweets.

Simply Sweet Caroline's is a charming cookie shop that offers a delightful selection of fresh and delicious custom cookies. The shop is identified as women-owned and a small business, adding a personal touch to every order. Customers can enjoy kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and delivery options. Appointment is required for planning, and credit and debit cards are accepted for payments.

With a stellar 5.0 rating, the shop has received glowing reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points from the reviews:

• The custom cookies are not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious, impressing guests at events.
• The ordering process is easy, and the pickup experience is seamless, making it convenient for customers.
• The personal touches added to the cookies make them perfect for special occasions, earning praise for both taste and design.

With appealing designs and mouth-watering flavors, Simply Sweet Caroline's will surely delight customers with their custom cookie creations. Visit their website and treat yourself to some sweet indulgence!

Cloud Cookie is a delightful cookie shop located in Chicago that offers a variety of sweet treats for all cookie enthusiasts. Customers can enjoy service options such as no-contact delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. The shop is also wheelchair-accessible, ensuring that everyone can indulge in their delicious desserts.

The reviews speak for themselves, with a rating of 4.7 based on 302 reviews. Here are some key points from customer feedback:

• Delicious cookies that rival those from a well-known chain
• Professional and friendly service from the owner
• Fast shipping and beautifully packaged cookies
• Unique and flavorful cookie options, including vegan and specialty cookies

Customers rave about the freshness and taste of the cookies, with highlights on the Basic Bish, cinnamon roll cookie with cream cheese frosting, snickerdoodle, and vegan chocolate cookie. The shop's clean and cute ambiance adds to the overall experience, making it a must-visit for cookie lovers in the area. Don't miss out on the chance to try these heavenly cookies at Cloud Cookie!

Big Fat Cookie is the ultimate cookie shop in Chicago that offers a variety of mouth-watering treats. Customers can enjoy convenient kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options. The dining experience focuses on delicious desserts, perfect for a quick visit. Customers can easily pay with credit cards for their orders.

With a stellar rating of 4.9, it's no wonder Big Fat Cookie has received rave reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points from their reviews:

• The cookies are big, fat, and delicious, with exceptional customer service.
• Customers love the creative flavors and the convenience of ordering from the window or website.
• The cookies are perfect for gifting, with the option to freeze them for later enjoyment.
• The cookies are so delicious that customers find it hard to resist and keep coming back for more.

So, next time you're craving a sweet treat in Chicago, don't miss out on the delectable cookies at Big Fat Cookie!

Brun Cookies is a beloved Dessert shop located in Chicago, IL. This quaint spot offers a variety of decadent cookies that have customers raving. The business provides Delivery, In-store pick-up, and Takeaway options for convenience.

The service at Brun Cookies is top-notch according to reviews. Customers emphasize the friendly and knowledgeable staff who are eager to walk them through the flavors. The cookies at Brun Cookies are described as flavorful and not overly sweet, making them a stand-out in the cookie world.

Here are some summarized reviews:

• An amazing experience with super friendly and knowledgeable staff, great flavors, and better than Crumbl cookies.
• The best cookies in Chicago city with every flavor being an experience, accompanied by kind and lovely staff.
• Although pricier, the cookies are good, well-presented, and offer a filled and fresh taste, comparable to other premium cookie shops.
• Customers are impressed by the huge cookies, delicious flavors, and crispy edges with a gooey center, complemented by the nice staff.

For cookie lovers and those looking for a sweet treat, Brun Cookies is a must-visit spot that promises to satisfy your cravings and leave you coming back for more.

Insomnia Cookies is a beloved cookie shop located in Chicago, IL. They offer a variety of services to cater to every customer's needs, such as no-contact delivery, delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and same-day delivery. For those concerned about accessibility, they provide wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible toilet.

This popular spot specializes in desserts, offering a range of delicious cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers rave about the friendly service and the quick visit they can enjoy at Insomnia Cookies.

• Warm cookies served with milk or ice cream
• Tasty cookies with rich and decadent flavors
• Fast and friendly service with great recommendations
• Delicious cookies available for late-night cravings

Insomnia Cookies is a beloved cookie shop in Chicago that offers a variety of delicious warm cookies . Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and same-day delivery. The shop is known for its wheelchair-accessible entrance and toilets, making it inclusive for all. If you're planning a quick visit for a sweet treat, Insomnia Cookies is the place to go.

With a rating of 4.3 stars from 456 reviews, it's clear that customers love the experience at Insomnia Cookies. Some key points from their reviews include:

• Extensive cookie flavors to choose from
• Warm cookies served with milk or ice cream
• Friendly and helpful staff offering great suggestions
• Delicious cookies that are worth coming back for

Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in warm, tasty cookies at Insomnia Cookies. Fast and friendly service awaits you at this late-night cookie haven!

Butterfly Cookies LLC is a lovely cookie shop located in Chicago that offers a variety of delicious treats. They provide services such as Kerbside pickup, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, and Takeaway for customers' convenience. The bakery prides itself on being LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safe space, creating a welcoming environment for all. Customers rave about their experiences, with several key points standing out:

• Custom cookies for special occasions were not only visually perfect but also incredibly delicious.
• The horchata coffee is a must-try, along with their baked goods that receive high praise.
• The warm and welcoming atmosphere, friendly customer service, and pet-friendly policy were standout features for many visitors.
• Returning customers repeatedly mention the exceptional quality of the treats and the outstanding service provided by the mother and daughter duo running the shop.

These glowing reviews attest to the excellence of Butterfly Cookies LLC and make it a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth in Chicago.

Sweet Shot Cookies is a delightful Bakery located in Chicago. They offer a variety of services including No-contact delivery, Delivery, In-store pick-up, and Takeaway. Customers can enjoy the convenience of Credit cards payments.

With a rating of 4.7, this bakery has received positive feedback from its customers. Here are some key points from their reviews:

• Cute place with a diverse range of unique cookie combos. Friendly staff and adorable space, though cookies were a bit too sweet and crispy for some.
• Individually wrapped cookies were a huge hit at a birthday party. Great prices, easy to work with, and incredible cookies.
• Amazing cookies that make perfect gifts, especially for Valentine's day. Affordable pricing and the cookies freeze well.
• Best cookies in Chicago! Easy to order and the team is dedicated to providing a seamless experience.

Customers love the cookies at Sweet Shot Cookies and highly recommend trying them out. If you're in the area, don't miss the opportunity to satisfy your sweet tooth with their delicious treats!

Cookie Spin is a popular dessert shop located in Chicago that offers a variety of sweet treats to satisfy any craving. Customers can enjoy delivery service, in-store pick-up, or takeaway options. The shop is wheelchair-accessible and caters to those looking for a quick visit.

Customer reviews rave about the delicious cookies, ice cream, shakes, and sundaes offered at Cookie Spin. Some key points from the reviews include:

• Delicious and high-quality treats with unique flavors
• Fast and friendly service with a variety of options to choose from
• Peanut butter sauce and fluffernutter shake highly recommended
• Spacious seating areas inside and outside with a clean environment

With a rating of 4.2 stars from 322 reviews, Cookie Spin continues to delight customers with its tasty creations. Visit their website to explore the menu and treat yourself to a delectable experience!

Insomnia Cookies is a beloved cookie shop in Chicago known for its delicious treats and convenient service options. Customers can enjoy delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options. The shop offers a cozy, late-night cookie atmosphere, perfect for satisfying those sweet cravings.

• Yummy cookies, quick service, and a great variety of flavors make this shop a go-to for cookie lovers.
• Fresh, warm cookies and friendly staff create a welcoming and enjoyable experience for customers.
• Reasonably priced cookies and the option for gluten-free/vegan treats cater to a diverse range of preferences.

Whether you're in the mood for a classic chocolate chip cookie or want to try something new like an ice cream sandwich, Insomnia Cookies has something for everyone. Check them out for a tasty and satisfying treat experience!

You're a Cookie! is a Wholesale bakery located in Chicago that offers a wide variety of delicious cookies for every taste. They are known for their innovative flavors and options for customers with allergies. Whether you're looking for a classic chocolate chip or a unique vegan creation, You're a Cookie! has something for everyone.

Customer reviews highlight the following key points:

• Wide variety of flavors available
• Options for customers with allergies
• Passionate owner dedicated to making delicious cookies
• Friendly and helpful staff

With a 4.6 rating, You're a Cookie! has quickly become a favorite spot for sweet treats in the area. Don't miss out on the opportunity to try their mouth-watering cookies and experience the passion and dedication that goes into each batch.

Insomnia Cookies is a popular cookie shop in Chicago that offers a variety of delicious treats to satisfy your sweet cravings. Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and even same-day delivery. The shop is known for its accessibility with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it convenient for all customers.

Customers rave about the warm and fresh cookies served at Insomnia Cookies, along with the excellent customer service provided by the staff. Some key points from customer reviews include:

• Warm and fresh cookies with exceptional customer service.
• Delicious cookies and brownies that are gooey and fresh.
• Staff members are friendly, kind, and provide great recommendations for cookie combinations.
• Customers love the variety of options available, including creative recipes like salted caramel, s'mores, and peanut butter cup cookies.

So, if you're in the mood for a tasty treat and exceptional service, be sure to visit Insomnia Cookies for an unforgettable dessert experience!