The 16 Best Carrot Cake Chicago

For those in search of the best carrot cake in Chicago, look no further. This beloved classic dessert has long been a favorite among locals and visitors alike, with its moist cake layers, creamy frosting, and perfectly spiced flavors.
Whether you're craving a slice of carrot cake for a special occasion or simply looking to satisfy a sweet tooth, Chicago offers a variety of options to choose from. From bakeries to cafes to restaurants, there's a carrot cake out there for everyone's taste preferences.
- Price range
- Size options
- Delivery or pickup available
- Customer reviews and ratings
With so many choices available, it can be overwhelming to decide where to get your fix of carrot cake. To help you narrow down your options, we've curated a list of the 16 best carrot cakes in Chicago. Read on to find your new favorite dessert spot!
- 1. Roeser's Bakery
- 2. Jennivee's Bakery
- 3. Sweet Mandy B's Bakery
- 4. Magnolia Bakery - Chicago
- 5. Lucy's Delights Bakery
- 6. Nothing Bundt Cakes
- 7. Lutz Bakery
- 8. Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe
- 9. Sweet Mandy B's Bakery
- 10. Wagner's Bakery
- 11. Artemio Bakery
- 12. Alliance Bakery — Division
- 13. Skinny Piggy Bakery
- 14. Ace Bakery
- 15. West Town Bakery
- 16. Cal's Bakery & Cafe

- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Wednesday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Thursday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Saturday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: 7 AM–6 PM
1. Roeser's Bakery
Information and Reviews
The bakery accepts various forms of payment, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. Additionally, they accommodate SNAP/EBT transactions for those utilizing this service.
Customer reviews highlight the exceptional quality of the baked goods offered at Roeser's Bakery. Here are some key points summarizing their feedback:
- Fresh and delicious donuts and pastries, with friendly and helpful service
- Soft and fresh cakes that exceed expectations, demonstrating great customer service
- Disappointing experiences with customized cake orders, raising concerns about customer service
- Delightful buttercream cakes, although some flavors and textures may not suit all tastes

- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday: 12–11 PM
- Wednesday: 12–11 PM
- Thursday: 12–11 PM
- Friday: 12–11 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–11 PM
- Sunday: 12–9 PM
2. Jennivee's Bakery
Information and Reviews
Customers have shared their experiences with Jennivee's Bakery through reviews. Here are some key points from their feedback:
- Disappointed with the cake received, lacking the promised flavors and presentation.
- Despite visual errors, the cakes are delicious and worth trying.
- Orders not meeting expectations in terms of design and consistency.
- Highly recommended for special occasions, providing beautiful and delicious cakes and cupcakes.
With a rating of 4.6, Jennivee's Bakery stands out as a quality establishment where customers can indulge in tasty treats and enjoy top-notch service. Whether you're planning a quick visit or looking for a unique celebratory cake, Jennivee's Bakery has something to offer for everyone.

- Monday: 9 AM–5 PM
- Tuesday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Wednesday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Thursday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 9 AM–8 PM
- Saturday: 8 AM–8 PM
- Sunday: 8 AM–6 PM
3. Sweet Mandy B's Bakery
Information and Reviews
The bakery has garnered a stellar rating of 4.6 based on 516 reviews. Here are a few key points from customer reviews:
- Warm hospitality and fabulous baking
- Beautiful custom cakes perfect for special occasions
- Delicious variety of cupcakes and cookies
- Charming ambiance and attentive customer service
Customers rave about the quality of the cakes, cupcakes, and cookies offered at Sweet Mandy B's Bakery, making it a must-visit bakery in the Chicago area. Visit their website for more information and to place your order today!

- Monday: 10 AM–7:30 PM
- Tuesday: 10 AM–7:30 PM
- Wednesday: 10 AM–7:30 PM
- Thursday: 10 AM–7:30 PM
- Friday: 10 AM–8:30 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–8:30 PM
- Sunday: 10 AM–7:30 PM
4. Magnolia Bakery - Chicago
Information and Reviews
With a 4.3 rating based on 2255 reviews, Magnolia Bakery has garnered praise for its delicious offerings. Customers have highlighted a few key points:
- Delicious banana pudding with a balanced blend of flavors.
- Warm and welcoming ambiance with knowledgeable staff.
- Unique and tasty icebox cake, perfect for special occasions.
- Quality desserts, such as cheesecakes and signature banana pudding.
Customers like Grace Mitton, Ciara, and Meg Rickman have shared their positive experiences at Magnolia Bakery, praising the flavors, service, and unique desserts offered. From nostalgic banana puddings to delightful icebox cakes, Magnolia Bakery is a must-visit for those with a sweet tooth looking for a memorable treat in the heart of Chicago.

5. Lucy's Delights Bakery
Information and Reviews
- The attention to detail and the exquisite flavor of the cakes are beyond compare.
- Customers are delighted by the level of communication and the ease of working with Lucy to bring their vision to life.
- The cakes not only look stunning but also taste divine, making every celebration truly memorable.
- Lucy's talent for creating custom designs that capture the essence of each event shines through in every cake she bakes.

- Monday: 10 AM–2 PM
- Tuesday: 9 AM–7 PM
- Wednesday: 9 AM–7 PM
- Thursday: 9 AM–7 PM
- Friday: 9 AM–7 PM
- Saturday: 9 AM–5 PM
- Sunday: 10 AM–4 PM
6. Nothing Bundt Cakes
Information and Reviews
With a rating of 4.8, Nothing Bundt Cakes has received positive feedback from many customers. Some key points from reviews include:
- The staff is friendly and engaging, providing excellent customer service.
- Customers appreciate the wide selection of delicious flavors available.
- Although some find the prices a bit high, they still highly recommend trying their treats.
- There is praise for the cleanliness of the store and the variety of desserts offered.
If you're looking for a memorable treat or a sweet gift for someone special, Nothing Bundt Cakes is a top choice in Chicago.

- Monday: 7 AM–8 PM
- Tuesday: 7 AM–8 PM
- Wednesday: 7 AM–8 PM
- Thursday: 7 AM–8 PM
- Friday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Saturday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Sunday: 8 AM–8 PM
7. Lutz Bakery
Information and Reviews
- The cakes boast a perfect balance of sweetness and texture, catering to diverse palates.
- There is a wide variety of flavors available, from classic options to innovative creations.
- While the treats are delicious, some customers have noted that communication and customer service could be improved to enhance the overall experience.
Whether you're looking for a special birthday cake or a sweet treat to enjoy, Lutz Bakery is a neighborhood favorite that promises to delight your taste buds. Visit their website for more information and treat yourself to a delightful culinary experience.

- Monday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Tuesday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Wednesday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Thursday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Saturday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: 7 AM–6 PM
8. Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe
Information and Reviews
With a stellar rating of 4.4, based on 391 reviews, it's clear that customers have a lot of love for Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe. Some key points from customer reviews include:
- Delicious pastries and excellent coffee
- Beautifully decorated shop with friendly and quick staff
- Quaint bakery with amazing custom cakes
- Wide variety of pastries and cake options
Whether you're stopping by for your morning coffee and croissant or looking to order a custom cake for a special occasion, Bittersweet Pastry Shop & Cafe has you covered. Visit their website for more information and treat yourself to something sweet today!

- Monday: 9 AM–5 PM
- Tuesday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Wednesday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Thursday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Saturday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: 9 AM–6 PM
9. Sweet Mandy B's Bakery
Information and Reviews
Customer reviews rave about the bakery's offerings. Some key points from the reviews include:
- A customer praises the delicious cupcakes, chocolate brownie, and sugar cookie, claiming it's better than other nearby options.
- Another customer enjoyed the Banana Caramel Cabinet pudding, describing it as a moist and tasty cupcake/bread pudding combination, along with other decent treats.
- One customer found the lemon bar too creamy and soft, with flavors that did not meet their expectations.
- Customers love the BEST cupcakes, Banana bread, and the bakery being open 7 days a week, all while receiving fast and friendly service.
With a 4.5 rating and numerous satisfied customers, Sweet Mandy B's Bakery is a must-visit for anyone looking for a delightful sweet treat experience in Chicago.

- Monday: 5 AM–9 PM
- Tuesday: 5 AM–9 PM
- Wednesday: 5 AM–9 PM
- Thursday: 5 AM–9 PM
- Friday: 5 AM–9 PM
- Saturday: 5 AM–9 PM
- Sunday: 7 AM–8 PM
10. Wagner's Bakery
Information and Reviews
Customers have praised Wagner's Bakery for its warm and friendly atmosphere. Some key points from customer reviews include:
- Best bakery by far with delicious coffee.
- Great selection of bread and cakes.
- Excellent cakes but inconsistent customer service.
- A go-to place for birthday cakes with amazing staff.

- Monday: 6 AM–7 PM
- Tuesday: 6 AM–7 PM
- Wednesday: 6 AM–7 PM
- Thursday: 6 AM–7 PM
- Friday: 6 AM–7 PM
- Saturday: 6 AM–7 PM
- Sunday: 6 AM–7 PM
11. Artemio Bakery
Information and Reviews
This bakery has garnered a 4.3-star rating from 287 reviews, with customers praising the wide selection of treats and the reasonable prices. Some key points from customer reviews include:
- Best Bakery in the city with inexpensive, delicious options
- Huge selection of cookies and baked goods, with standout coconut macaroons
- Amazing sprinkle cookies, cream horns, and other treats at great value
- Excellent customer service and welcoming atmosphere
Indulge in the wonderful world of baked goods at Artemio Bakery and treat yourself to something sweet today!

- Monday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Tuesday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Wednesday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Thursday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Friday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Saturday: 7 AM–9 PM
- Sunday: 7 AM–9 PM
12. Alliance Bakery — Division
Information and Reviews
Customer reviews highlight key points about Alliance Bakery — Division:
- Good pastries, coffee, and custom cakes are a highlight, but variety has decreased over time. The lack of seating may not be ideal for those looking to work or relax.
- A disappointment in the size and quality of a chocolate croissant expressed by a customer, highlighting the importance of first impressions and value for money.
- Praises for the bakery's long-standing reputation and quality products, emphasizing the cute cake decorations and relaxing atmosphere.
- Complaints about the overly sweet treats and lackluster customer service, questioning the current standards compared to previous experiences.
With a rating of 4.2 and numerous positive reviews, Alliance Bakery — Division continues to be a favorite spot for locals and visitors looking to indulge in delightful baked goods.

- Monday: 9 AM–7:30 PM
- Tuesday: 9 AM–7:30 PM
- Wednesday: 9 AM–7:30 PM
- Thursday: 9 AM–7:30 PM
- Friday: 9 AM–7:30 PM
- Saturday: 9 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: Closed
13. Skinny Piggy Bakery
Information and Reviews
- Sugar-free cakes that are a hit with keto enthusiasts.
- Top-notch delivery service with excellent communication.
- Exceptional customer experience and attention to detail.
- Beautifully crafted cakes that are almost too pretty to eat.
The bakery's focus on providing delectable sugar-free options has garnered it a stellar rating of 4.5 stars from 84 reviews. Whether you're looking for a custom cake for a special occasion or simply want to indulge guilt-free, Skinny Piggy Bakery is the place to go. Visit their website to explore their tempting range of treats and place an order today!

- Monday: 6 AM–6 PM
- Tuesday: 6 AM–6 PM
- Wednesday: 6 AM–6 PM
- Thursday: 6 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 6 AM–6 PM
- Saturday: 7 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: Closed
14. Ace Bakery
Information and Reviews
With an impressive rating of 4.0 stars from 497 reviews, Ace Bakery has garnered positive feedback from its customers. Here are some key points from their reviews:
- Personalized cakes with excellent customer service
- Delicious and beautifully decorated cakes
- Knowledgeable and patient staff
- Fresh and mouth-watering treats
If you are looking for a bakery that not only satisfies your sweet tooth but also provides top-notch customer service, Ace Bakery is the place to visit!

- Monday: 7 AM–12 PM
- Tuesday: 7 AM–12 PM
- Wednesday: 7 AM–12 PM
- Thursday: 7 AM–12 PM
- Friday: 7 AM–12 PM
- Saturday: 7 AM–12 PM
- Sunday: 7 AM–12 PM
15. West Town Bakery
Information and Reviews
- Friendly staff and delicious pastries, especially the chocolate muffin and fluffy donuts
- Unique infused beverages and heavenly lemonade
- Concerns about food safety and customer service

16. Cal's Bakery & Cafe
Information and Reviews
Customer reviews showcase the unique experiences shared by patrons. Key points from the reviews include:
- One customer appreciated the amazing cake and cake pops made on short notice but mentioned difficulty in contacting via the website.
- Another customer expressed disappointment in a cake order for their son's birthday, highlighting a lack of communication and unmet expectations.
- A negative review mentioned a canceled order with no communication or refund provided, leading to frustration and disappointment.
- A positive review detailed a successful wedding cake order, commending the baker for going above and beyond expectations.
With a rating of 3.2 and a diverse range of services, Cal's Bakery & Cafe strives to create memorable experiences for all customers, ensuring satisfaction and delicious treats every time.
Map of Carrot Cake Chicago
Indulge in the deliciously moist and spiced carrot cake offerings across Chicago with this handy map. Whether you're in search of a classic slice or a unique spin on this beloved dessert, this map will guide you to the best carrot cake spots in the city. Explore all the delicious options Chicago has to offer for your next sweet treat adventure.
Related Services