Menu

The 14 Best Antique Jewelry Appraisal Chicago

For those seeking reliable and expert appraisal services for their antique jewelry in Chicago, finding the right professional can be a crucial decision. Whether you are looking to assess the value of a family heirloom or determine the authenticity of a recent find, it's important to choose a knowledgeable and trusted expert.

With a variety of options available in the Chicago area, it can be overwhelming to narrow down the choices. To make the decision-making process easier, here is a list of the top antique jewelry appraisal services in Chicago to help you compare and find the best option for your needs.

Make an informed decision by comparing the top antique jewelry appraisal services in Chicago listed below:

How this ranking works

Before ranking this guide we review each business's track record, what its customers say and how clearly it explains its work. The result is an editorial selection that we update as things change.

Some businesses pay for a fuller profile or a featured position. It is only open to those that have already passed our selection, and it is always marked.

Top 3Full rankingMapTips for choosing

Our 14 local picks compared

The Classic Gem (Appointments Only), Chicago#1
What sets it apart
  • Attentive and knowledgeable staff

  • Effortless and personalized process

  • Reasonable prices and high-quality jewelry

  • Memorable and enjoyable shopping experience

The Classic Gem (Appointments Only)

5.062 reviews
2514 N Halsted St, Chicago, IL 60614, United States

The Classic Gem is a renowned jewelry designer in Chicago, IL, praised for their exceptional services and customer satisfaction. Their appointments-only model ensures personalized attention and a stress-free shopping experience. Customers rave about their experience at The Classic Gem, highlighting several key points:

The business offers various service options like kerbside pickup, online appointments, delivery, in-store pick-up, and same-day delivery. Additionally, they are LGBTQ+ friendly and provide wheelchair-accessible facilities. With a perfect 5.0 rating from happy customers, The Classic Gem is the go-to destination for stunning and personalized jewelry pieces.

Costello Jewelry Company, Chicago#2
What sets it apart
  • Customers rave about the knowledgeable and friendly staff who provide high-quality service at great prices.

  • Whether you need jewelry repairs or are looking for a beautiful engagement ring, Costello Jewelry Company is the place to go.

  • Customers appreciate the efficient and personalized customer service they receive, making each visit a pleasant experience.

  • From quick repairs to custom-made pieces, Costello Jewelry Company goes above and beyond to meet their customers' needs.

Costello Jewelry Company

5.0307 reviews
474 N Main St, Glen Ellyn, IL 60137, United States

Costello Jewelry Company is a top-notch jewelry store located in Glen Ellyn, IL. With a perfect rating of 5.0 stars, it's clear that customers have nothing but praise for this establishment.

Experience the excellence of Costello Jewelry Company and see why customers keep coming back for all their jewelry needs!

Bella Cosa Jewelers, Willowbrook Illinois, Chicago#3
What sets it apart
  • Had a wonderful experience. Michelle helped explore options beyond specifications.

  • Always the BEST customer service. They will find exactly what you're looking for!

  • Phenomenal service. Mary went above and beyond to help find the perfect gift.

  • Top-notch experience. Unique and hand-selected pieces. Great services and great jewelry!

Bella Cosa Jewelers, Willowbrook Illinois

4.9958 reviews
7163 South Kingery Hwy, Willowbrook, IL 60527, United States

Bella Cosa Jewelers in Willowbrook, Illinois, is a renowned jewelry store that offers a wide selection of unique and beautiful pieces. Their service options include kerbside pickup, in-store pick-up, and in-store shopping. Customers appreciate the exceptional repair services provided by the skilled staff. The store is known for being LGBTQ+ friendly and offers various payment options, including credit cards and NFC mobile payments.

With a stellar rating of 4.9, Bella Cosa Jewelers has received glowing reviews from satisfied customers:

A & R Estate Buyers, Chicago#4
What sets it apart
  • Keith is professional, accommodating, and highly recommended.

  • Customers appreciate Keith's integrity, thoroughness, and trustworthiness.

  • Keith provides options, information, and no-pressure evaluations.

  • Customers find the experience outstanding, transparent, and informative.

A & R Estate Buyers

5.020 reviews
1445 W Belmont Ave, Chicago, IL 60657, United States

A & R Estate Buyers is a reputable gold dealer located in Chicago. They offer a range of services, including delivery options and appointments for evaluations. Customers have left glowing reviews, highlighting Keith's professionalism, honesty, and expertise. Some key points from the reviews include:

With a perfect rating of 5.0 stars, A & R Estate Buyers continues to impress customers with exceptional service and expertise.

Rose Estate Jewelers, Chicago#5
What sets it apart
  • Exceptional customer service and knowledge of jewelry value.

  • Family-friendly atmosphere that makes customers feel welcome and valued.

  • Competitive pricing and fair offers for buying and selling jewelry.

Rose Estate Jewelers

5.027 reviews
5 S Wabash Ave # 808, Chicago, IL 60603, United States

Rose Estate Jewelers is a renowned jewelry buyer located in Chicago, IL. They offer various services and features to cater to their customers' needs. Customers have left glowing reviews for Rose Estate Jewelers, highlighting the following key points:

The business provides repair services and accepts credit cards for payments. Customers rave about their experiences, mentioning the expertise of the staff and the fair prices offered for their jewelry. Visit Rose Estate Jewelers for a memorable and satisfactory jewelry buying or selling experience.

West Town Jewelry & Loan, Chicago#6
What sets it apart
  • Professional and respectful service, making the selling process easy and comfortable.

  • Highly recommended for wedding bands and family ring appraisals.

  • Easy and informative experience when selling items, with great education on item value.

  • Quick, efficient, and honest service with high payouts for jewelry, making it the best place to sell unwanted items in Chicago.

West Town Jewelry & Loan

4.9199 reviews
2059 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60622, United States

West Town Jewelry & Loan is a reputable pawn shop located in the heart of Chicago. Offering services such as in-store pick-up and shopping, the business prides itself on being LGBTQ+ friendly and having a wheelchair-accessible entrance. Customers have praised the owner, Gabe, for his professionalism and transparency. Some key points from customer reviews include:

With a rating of 4.9 and numerous positive reviews, West Town Jewelry & Loan is a go-to spot for those looking to buy, sell, or pawn jewelry and other valuable items.

Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co, Chicago#7
What sets it apart
  • Customers rave about the personalized service and expertise of the staff.

  • The store is known for its excellent craftsmanship and attention to detail.

  • Many customers appreciate the quick turnaround time and reasonable prices.

Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co

4.9195 reviews
5139 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60640, United States

Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co is a renowned jewelry store in Chicago that offers a wide range of services to meet all your jewelry needs. From custom ring settings to resizing, soldering, and repair services, Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co has got you covered. The store prides itself on providing a personal touch and a neighborhood feel, making every customer feel valued and important.

Whether you're looking to create a custom piece or need repairs done, Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co is the place to go for all your jewelry needs. Shop local and experience the superior customer service, quality, and trust that this business is known for.

Midwest Diamond Buyers, Chicago#8
What sets it apart
  • An amazing experience with Shlomi. Very professional and informative. Will be coming back.

  • Amazing rates. Always come back.

  • Albert was very professional, fair, and honest. Will deal with him in the future.

  • Sold beautiful gold pieces and was very happy with the price offered. Professional and kind staff.

Midwest Diamond Buyers

5.073 reviews
29 E Madison St #1818-2, Chicago, IL 60602, United States

Midwest Diamond Buyers is a reputable jewelry buyer located in Chicago, IL. They offer a range of service options including in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and same-day delivery. The business is accessible with features like a wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance. Customers appreciate the professionalism and fair pricing provided by the staff.

Here are some summarized reviews:

Beverley R, Chicago#9
What sets it apart
  • Deep knowledge of each piece's history and craftsmanship

  • Respectful of customer budget and preferences

  • Extensive collection of high-quality antique jewelry

Beverley R

5.055 reviews
172 E Walton Pl, Chicago, IL 60611, United States

Beverley R Jewelry store offers a unique experience for those seeking antique and vintage jewelry pieces. Customers rave about the knowledgeable and friendly service provided by Stephen, the owner. Some of the key points highlighted in the reviews include:

These reviews reflect the exceptional service and quality of products available at Beverley R. Visit their store in Chicago, IL to find the perfect piece for your special occasion.

Lester Lampert, Chicago#10
What sets it apart
  • Impressed by the quality of work and custom design process for a sentimental piece of jewelry.

  • Excellent service and communication from knowledgeable staff.

  • Extraordinary attention to detail and respect in creating custom-made pieces.

  • Warm and welcoming environment with professional and accommodating staff.

Lester Lampert

5.036 reviews
7 E Huron St, Chicago, IL 60611, United States

Lester Lampert is a top-rated jewelry store that offers a wide range of services and features for its customers. They provide kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and even same-day delivery options for added convenience. The business is highly accessible with wheelchair-accessible entrance, seating, and toilet facilities available. In terms of offerings, they provide top-notch repair services to keep your jewelry in pristine condition.

Customers have shared glowing reviews about their experiences at Lester Lampert. Some key points from the reviews include:

These reviews highlight the exceptional service, craftsmanship, and personal touch that customers can expect when visiting Lester Lampert in Chicago.

House of Kahn Estate Jewelers, Chicago#12
What sets it apart
  • Customers describe their experiences as exceptional, claiming it to be the best when buying or selling jewelry.

  • Visitors find a diverse collection of estate jewelry, with some expressing joy in finding their dream pieces at House of Kahn.

  • Shoppers appreciate the variety and quality of items available, from fine jewelry to costume pieces, at fantastic prices.

  • The ambiance of the store is described as welcoming, with staff members being friendly and attentive to customers' needs.

House of Kahn Estate Jewelers

5.05 reviews
900 N Michigan Ave L5-12, Chicago, IL 60611, United States

House of Kahn Estate Jewelers is a renowned establishment located in Chicago, offering exquisite estate jewelry. The business prides itself on a wide selection of fine jewelry, including gold, silver, diamonds, and precious stones. Customers rave about the impeccable service provided by professional staff like Tobina, who is praised for her expertise and outstanding customer care.

A-1 Jewelry & Coin Buyers, Chicago#13
What sets it apart
  • Ralph and his team were super helpful. Quick and easy visit!

  • The staff was extremely professional and very helpful through the entire process.

  • Dealt with Ralph, super helpful and knowledgeable. The whole process was smooth and a pleasure working with him.

  • John was awesome! Helped me pick out a beautiful ring and a watch for my boyfriend! Great store.

A-1 Jewelry & Coin Buyers

4.4109 reviews
1827 W Irving Park Rd, Chicago, IL 60613, United States

A-1 Jewelry & Coin Buyers is a reputable jewelry buyer located in Chicago. They offer a range of services to their customers, including repair services and efficient delivery options for their convenience. The business is also LGBTQ+ friendly and ensures a safe space for everyone who walks through their doors.

With a high rating of 4.4 stars, customers have shared positive feedback about their experiences. Here are some key points from their reviews:

These reviews highlight the excellent customer service and expertise that A-1 Jewelry & Coin Buyers provides to their customers. Whether you are looking to sell jewelry or purchase new items, this business is a top choice in the Chicago area.

CIRCA, Chicago#14
What sets it apart
  • One customer praised the professionalism and efficiency of the transaction, recommending both CIRCA and the representative, Carter.

  • Another client was delighted with the thoroughness and knowledge displayed by Carter, calling the experience a pleasure.

  • A different review highlighted the honesty and fair pricing offered by CIRCA, making the process of selling jewelry a positive and rewarding one.

  • Many customers have commended CIRCA for its professionalism, friendliness, and honesty over the years, making it their go-to place for recycling jewelry pieces.

CIRCA

4.429 reviews
875 N Michigan Ave Ste 1370, Chicago, IL 60611, United States

CIRCA is a renowned establishment in Chicago known for its exceptional services in buying jewelry, diamonds, and watches. The business prides itself on providing professional and efficient transactions, as highlighted by numerous positive reviews.

With a rating of 4.4 and a strong reputation for excellence in customer service, CIRCA continues to be a top choice for individuals looking to sell their precious items with confidence.

The comparison in brief

Is your business listed here?

Claim or add my business

Map of Antique Jewelry Appraisal Chicago

Looking to get your antique jewelry appraised in Chicago? Our comprehensive map displays all the top-rated appraisal services in the city, providing you with a convenient way to find the most reputable professionals in the industry. Whether you are looking to sell, insure, or simply value your precious items, trust these experts to give you an accurate and trustworthy appraisal.

Tips for choosing antique jewelry appraisal in Chicago

  1. Expertise in evaluating various types of antique jewelry.
  2. Accurate assessments of value and authenticity.
  3. Professional and trustworthy service.
  4. Convenient location in Chicago area.

More guides like this